Complete Guide to the Caught Red Handed Quest in Skyrim

Introduction

In "Skyrim," the Caught Red Handed quest is part of the Thieves Guild questline that introduces players to the world of crime and stealth. During this quest, you are tasked with helping Brynjolf catch an errant thief, making it a pivotal moment for players looking to advance in the Thieves Guild. This guide will provide you with a detailed step-by-step walkthrough to ensure you complete this quest successfully.

Step-by-Step Walkthrough

1. Start the Quest

   • After completing the quest "Taking Care of Business," speak to Brynjolf in the Ratway.
     • He will introduce the idea of catching an unsuspecting thief, Malven, and prompt you to join in.
     • Accept the quest by choosing the dialogue option that conveys your willingness to help him.

2. Follow Brynjolf to the Marketplace

   • Leave the Ratway and head to the marketplace in Riften.
     • Keep an eye on your surroundings, as this area is bustling with NPCs who might interfere.
     • As you approach the market area, Brynjolf will automatically lead you to a good vantage point.

3. Watch the Thief

   • Once you’re at the marketplace, Brynjolf will indicate where Malven will appear.
     • Stand back and observe the interaction between Malven and a merchant, Grelka.
     • Be patient, as Malven will attempt to steal from Grelka, which will trigger the next phase of the quest.

4. Confront the Thief

   • As soon as Malven steals from Grelka, Brynjolf will instruct you to go after him.
     • Chase Malven through the market; he will initially try to evade capture.
     • Corner him in an alley or near a building to confront him directly.

5. Initiate Dialogue with Malven

   • Approach Malven and initiate dialogue.
     • You will have various options, but choose the one that allows you to confront him about his thieving activities.
     • This dialogue will culminate in a confrontation where you can either persuade or intimidate him.

6. Decide Malven's Fate

   • You will have a choice: let him go or take him back to Brynjolf.
     • If you persuade him successfully, he will talk about the Thieves Guild, and you may choose to let him go.
     • If you decide to take him back, you will need to lead him towards Brynjolf in the Ratway.

7. Return to Brynjolf

   • Once you have dealt with Malven, return to Brynjolf.
     • Speak to him about the confrontation and what you’ve learned from Malven.
     • This dialogue will reveal more about the Thieves Guild and unlock subsequent quests.

8. Complete the Quest

   • After your discussion with Brynjolf, he will reward you for your efforts.
     • The quest will officially come to an end, and your reputation within the Thieves Guild will increase.
     • You will also gain experience points, gold, and possibly some useful items.

Conclusion

Completing the Caught Red Handed quest is a fundamental stepping stone in your journey through “Skyrim.” It introduces you to the dynamics of the Thieves Guild and helps cement your role as a significant player in the criminal underworld. Following this detailed guide will ensure you navigate the quest smoothly and benefit from the rewards that come with it. Happy thieving!