Mastering the "Confidence Man" Quest in Fallout 4

Introduction

The "Confidence Man" quest in Fallout 4 introduces players to a rich narrative filled with deception and moral choices. Taking place in the Goodneighbor settlement, this quest immerses players in the underbelly of a post-apocalyptic society where trust is a rare commodity. This guide aims to provide a comprehensive step-by-step walkthrough to help you navigate this quest, ensuring you achieve success regardless of the decisions you make.

Step-by-Step Walkthrough

1. Starting the Quest

   • Begin your adventure in Goodneighbor. You can find your way here via several quests or simply exploring the Commonwealth.
   • Enter the Third Rail, a bar and hub for the local denizens.
   • Speak with a man named Eddie Winter. He will express concerns about a character named John “The Scribe”.

2. Gathering Information

   • After your conversation with Eddie Winter, you'll need to find John.
     • Objective: Locate John "The Scribe" in the Third Rail.
     • Head to the back of the bar where you’ll find John sitting alone at a table.
   • Speak with John and learn about his situation.
     • He will describe how Eddie is trying to con him.

3. Deciding Whom to Trust

   • At this point, you can choose to help either Eddie or John.
     • If you side with Eddie, you will receive a reward, but it may cost John his life.
     • If you side with John, you may potentially save him and gain different rewards.

4. Confront Eddie

   • If you choose to help John, approach Eddie and confront him.
     • Dialogue Options: Use persuasive dialogue to convince him to stand down.
     • You may need certain Charisma levels or perks so be prepared for potential challenges in dialogue.

5. Choosing the Outcome

   • Once you’ve confronted Eddie, the situation can escalate into a confrontation if he refuses to back down.
     • Combat Option: If you choose violence, prepare for a fight. Eddie is equipped with a melee weapon and will attack.
     • Non-Combat Option: If you succeed with dialogue, Eddie might back away leading to a peaceful resolution.

6. Wrapping Up the Quest

   • Regardless of the outcome, you will resolve the situation with Eddie and John.
   • Speak back to John to finalize your actions and reap any rewards from your chosen side.
     • You may receive caps, items, or new information about additional quests or the Goodneighbor area.

7. Returning to Goodneighbor

   • After dealing with Eddie and John, explore Goodneighbor.
     • You might want to talk to other locals for additional side quests or lore.
     • Ensure you save your game, as you can further explore or continue on with other quests in the Commonwealth.

Conclusion

Completing the "Confidence Man" quest offers insight into the complexities of Fallout 4's narrative and its characters. You are faced with choices that can lead to different outcomes and consequences. Whether you choose to support Eddie's deceitful ways or protect John’s hopeful innocence, the resolution is up to your discretion. Take these steps to master the quest and enjoy the vibrant world of Fallout 4 to its fullest.